Butter vs. Margarine – Who’s The Bad Guy?

Food can be confusing! What's good for you one day is labeled bad the next - or visa versa. Take butter, for instance. In the past, it was branded an evil food and something to avoid; the next day margarine was the bad guy.

So which is it? Let’s take a closer look at these two fatty flavorings and see if we can make some sense out of all the information we keep getting fed.

Suspect #1 - Butter

Basically speaking, butter is made by churning cream or milk - usually from cows - until the fat and liquid separate. Salt is often added for flavor and to keep the butter from spoiling.

Butter is roughly 80% milk fat, which is primarily saturated fatty acids. These fatty acids get their name because they are saturated with hydrogen ions. Because of this, they also have more energy (translation: calories). Also, a lot of these fatty acids can be packed together in a space (translation: your thighs/belly).

Saturated fats and heart disease: Saturated fats like to contribute to LDL’s (bad cholesterol) dirty work of hanging out in your arteries and setting up house by forming plaques along arterial walls. This slows and can even obstruct blood flow to and from the heart, increasing the risk of heart disease.

Unsaturated fats, on the other hand, are healthier than the saturated version. They got their name because…yep, they're not saturated with hydrogen ions. This also means unsaturated fats contain less energy (calories). I like these fats already!

A couple of drawbacks: The more unsaturated fats are, the easier it is for them to spoil. They also become a liquid relatively quickly at room temperature.

Most importantly, unsaturated fats don’t increase cholesterol and cause heart disease like the saturated fats do. So, if you've got to eat fat, try to make sure it’s unsaturated. Some sources of unsaturated fats can be found in avocados, walnuts, olive oil, and salmon.

Suspect #2 - Margarine

Margarine is commonly made from vegetable oils, making it a cholesterol-free spread (animal sources provide cholesterol). Margarine may have that going for it, but not all margarines are created equal. Many margarines, especially the earlier versions with their distinctive bright, yellow color, have trans fat added to them.

Trans fat doesn't come from a natural source. Trans fat is an unsaturated fat that has some hydrogen ions added to it. Now the fat has become partially hydrogenated. Manufacturers like to add hydrogen ions because they make margarine (and other foods with trans fat added to them) less likely to melt at room temperature or spoil quickly.

The problem is your body has absolutely no use for trans fat. Furthermore, trans fats cause the body harm. They're proficient at increasing your LDL (again, the bad stuff) while decreasing your HDL (the good cholesterol), causing hardening of the arteries, and leading to a greater risk of heart disease.

Better margarines: Many modern margarines these days lack trans fatty acids and are made with unsaturated oils. Benecol and Take Control are just a couple examples of the healthier margarines on the market.

So, who's the true "bad guy"?

The real bad guy here is the traditional margarine, which is made with harmful trans fatty acids. Try to avoid margarines - and all foods for that matter - with trans fat.

My first choice is to avoid butter and margarine completely, but that just isn't realistic (or fun)! When it comes to butter spreads, I would use the heart-healthy spreads first and butter as a second option.

That being said, remember that while some fats are better than others, they're still fat. And too much fat can…well, make you fat!

Case closed! ;)

Photo credit: bb matt

Originally posted 2007-12-03 08:00:13. Republished by Blog Post Promoter

Blog Traffic Exchange Related Posts
  • happyfoodEating a Healthy Balanced Diet Eating a healthy and balanced diet is capable of providing you with all of the nutrients and all of the calories that your body requires for the activities and challenges that are ahead of you. Knowing what foods are rich in helpful nutrients like vitamins, proteins and healthy fats while......
  • blog traffic exchangeGirl Scout Cookies - Wolves in Sheep's clothing? Girl Scout cookies seem to be everywhere these days! Coworkers bring in their child's cookie order sheet to work and encourage you to, "Just buy 8 boxes, and Jenny will get her badge!" Bubbly girls in green bombard you as you enter and exit the grocery store by displaying the......
  • yogurtwalnutsImproving Health with a Superfood Diet Choosing a superfood diet involves consuming a diet that is rich in superfoods. The purpose of a superfood diet is to provide you with a diet rich in the right nutrients through foods that improve your health. These superfoods are more than capable of creating a truly large impact on......
  • Don't eat too muchFun Facts about Calories A calorie (or kilocalorie) is a measurement of energy. 1 calorie = the amount of energy (heat) required to increase the temperature of 1 gram of water 1 degree Celsius (1.8 degrees Fahrenheit). There are 3500 calories for each pound of body fat. To lose one pound of stored fat,......
  • pearsappleEating a Healthy Balanced Diet Eating a healthy and balanced diet is capable of providing you with all of the nutrients and all of the calories that your body requires for the activities and challenges that are ahead of you. Knowing what foods are rich in helpful nutrients like vitamins, proteins and healthy fats while......
Blog Traffic Exchange Related Websites
  • kiwiWhat You May Not Know About Fat Most of are trained to recoil in horror at the mere mention of the word fat, and it automatically has negative connotations for most of us. However, there is such a thing as good fat, and if you’re trying to lose weight, it is important to make sure you are......
  • blog traffic exchangeMediterranean Diet Review Pros: Some dieters felt that there was a great variety. Some dieters felt that the food tasted great. Some dieters felt that it was relatively easy to stick to. Some dieters felt that they felt healthier. Some dieters felt that eating out was simple. Cons: Some dieters felt like this......
  • orange5 Simple Solutions to Weight Loss Are you tired of hard, complicated diets that simply do not produce the results that you are looking for? You are absolutely not alone, because there are people all over the world that are yearning for simple solutions to weight loss that will drive results. Research has shown that 98......
  • blog traffic exchange6 Ways to Beat Fatigue as you Battle your Weight This post was contributed by Heather Johnson, who writes on the subject of online nursing school. She invites your feedback at heatherjohnson2323 at gmail dot com. If you are interested in contributing a guest post please send me an email at kevin [at] weightladder (dot) com It’s all very well......
  • jumpstartJumpstart Medicine I highly recommend Jumpstart. In fact, I have a special offer for anyone in wanting to try Jumpstart in Redwood City or Mountain View: $25 off your first visit (just print it and bring it to your appointment). With four locations in California, Jump Start Medicine provides its patients with......
Online Stores If you liked this article, vote for it on del.icio.us and stumbleupon.


Categories:

Nutrition



2 comments ↓
#1 KM on 04.07.10 at 5:47 pm

This is utter bollocks… Do some more reserach and do it properly…

#2 Deb on 07.16.10 at 8:32 am

I’m so glad that some companies have started making margarine with olive oil. Much healthier!

Leave a Comment

3 fatty acids bad fats black olives breast cancer cancer cells Cravings daily basis diet exercise Exercises family history Fitness Food Journal fruits and vegetables health and wellness Health and Wellness health benefits healthy pregnancy high blood pressure hormones menstrual cycle menstrual period metabolism monounsaturated fats Motivation muscles nutrients Nutrition omega 3 fatty acids physical activity placenta polyunsaturated fats pregnancy pregnant women saturated fats skin care stop eating sugar sugar addicition Sugar Addiction sugar cravings uterus Weight Loss what this means whole grains